In a surprising development, Pittsburgh Penguins prospect Rutger McGroarty has been sent down to the AHL’s Wilkes-Barre/Scranton Penguins after just three games in the NHL.
This move follows a summer filled with trade rumors, as McGroarty felt he was not getting the opportunities he deserved with his previous team, the Winnipeg Jets. His wish for a fresh start came true when he was traded to the Penguins, but it appears that even with a new team, the path to regular NHL minutes remains elusive for the young forward.
What McGroarty’s Demotion Means for the Penguins and His Future
McGroarty, who had been a hot topic in NHL trade discussions, found himself on a roster that is juggling both veteran leadership and youthful potential. With three games under his belt this season, he was scratched in Pittsburgh’s last game—a clear sign that his minutes were diminishing. The Pens had played their fourth game in six nights, and McGroarty was sidelined as a healthy scratch.
Many fans speculate that the rigorous NHL schedule, which is far more demanding than the college-level competition McGroarty is used to, may have contributed to his demotion. It’s a challenging transition for any young player. By sending him to Wilkes-Barre, the Penguins are giving McGroarty a chance to play top-line minutes and develop his skills further rather than confining him to limited third-line minutes in Pittsburgh. This move should ultimately benefit his development, even if it comes as a disappointment in the short term.
However, some NHL fans are questioning the optics of this situation. One online commentator noted, “This kid stiffed his draft team (the Jets, a potential contender) to play for a Pittsburgh team that’s in a bit of a rebuilding phase, and now he’s in the AHL? This isn’t the ideal start to his new chapter.” Others have pointed out that players from the USA Hockey National Team Development Program (NTDP), like McGroarty, often struggle with demotions and may request trades again if they feel sidelined.
While the move is frustrating for both McGroarty and his supporters, it could be a long-term play for the Penguins, who have to balance their roster between seasoned veterans and developing prospects. Keeping McGroarty in the AHL could accelerate his growth, making him better suited for an NHL return later this season.
Stay connected to the latest NHL news
For the latest NHL news, online hockey pool to compete against fellow NHL fans, player point projections, and the NHL TV schedule, visit our website. Stay updated on everything hockey, and sign up for our newsletter below!
Sign up for our weekly NHL trade rumors newsletter