The Calgary Flames’ reported interest in Arber Xhekaj deserves another look because the Montreal Canadiens have reached the point where they must decide exactly how the rugged defenseman fits into their long-term plans.
Montreal Gazette reporter Herb Zurkowsky initially reported on March 3 that Calgary had shown interest in Xhekaj. That report did not suggest a trade was close, but it connected the Flames to one of the NHL’s most recognizable physical defenders. Five months later, Xhekaj remains an unsigned restricted free agent, giving the original rumor renewed relevance.
There is an important update, however: Calgary’s need for another defenseman is no longer as obvious. The Flames acquired Simon Nemec from the New Jersey Devils and signed him to a five-year contract carrying a $7.25 million annual cap hit. Calgary now projects to carry eight NHL defensemen, meaning Xhekaj would be more of a stylistic addition than an urgent roster requirement.
My read is that the Flames’ interest was legitimate, but circumstances have changed. A trade remains possible, but only if Calgary creates room and Montreal receives more than a modest draft pick.
Why the Calgary Flames Are Interested in Arber Xhekaj
Xhekaj Brings an Element Calgary Cannot Easily Replace
Xhekaj is not going to be acquired for his offensive production. The 25-year-old recorded one goal, three assists and 116 penalty minutes in 65 games during the 2025-26 regular season. He averaged just over 11 minutes of five-on-five ice time per game and finished with a 43 percent expected-goal share. Those numbers reflect a third-pairing defender rather than a player who should be trusted with top-four minutes.
What makes Xhekaj valuable is the element surrounding those numbers.
At 6-foot-4 and 240 pounds, he provides intimidation, heavy physical play and a willingness to defend teammates. Calgary already has size on its blue line, particularly with Kevin Bahl and Jake Middleton, but Xhekaj plays with a confrontational edge that can alter the temperature of a game.
That matters during an 82-game season. Skilled young players such as Zayne Parekh and Simon Nemec will inevitably face aggressive forechecking and physical pressure. Having Xhekaj available would give the Flames a defender capable of responding immediately.
The concern is whether that specialized role is worth the trade cost and a new contract.
NHLTradeRumor.com Calgary-Xhekaj Fit Model
| Category | Weight | Score | Analysis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Physicality and identity | 20% | 9/10 | Provides intimidation and protects Calgary’s young players. |
| Age and team control | 20% | 8/10 | Xhekaj is 25 and remains under restricted free-agent control. |
| Salary-cap fit | 20% | 9/10 | Calgary has enough projected space to absorb a reasonable contract. |
| Depth-chart opportunity | 25% | 5/10 | The Flames already project to have eight NHL defensemen. |
| Trade-cost efficiency | 15% | 6/10 | Montreal has little reason to sell a unique player at a discount. |
| Weighted fit score | 100% | 7.4/10 | A logical player-team match complicated by Calgary’s crowded blue line. |
Calgary Can Easily Afford Xhekaj’s Next Contract
Calgary currently projects to have approximately $14.88 million in salary-cap space with a 23-player roster. Xhekaj’s previous contract carried a $1.3 million cap hit, and his qualifying offer is also $1.3 million.
For illustration, a two-year contract worth $2.2 million annually would reduce Calgary’s projected space to approximately $12.68 million, assuming no salary is sent to Montreal and no other roster changes are made.
That makes the contract manageable. The real obstacle is finding a roster position.
Calgary currently lists Bahl, Middleton, Nemec, Parekh, Zach Whitecloud, Joel Hanley, Brayden Pachal and Yan Kuznetsov among its NHL defensemen. Xhekaj would become another left-shot option competing with Bahl, Middleton, Hanley and Kuznetsov.
A corresponding move would likely be necessary.
Why the Montreal Canadiens Could Consider a Trade
The Montreal Canadiens have their own numbers problem.
Noah Dobson, Lane Hutson, Kaiden Guhle, Mike Matheson, Alexandre Carrier and Jayden Struble are already established at the NHL level. David Reinbacher and Adam Engstrom are among the younger defensemen competing for future opportunities. Xhekaj’s unusual physical profile makes him difficult to replace, but it does not guarantee him regular minutes.
His playoff usage provided another clue. Xhekaj served as Montreal’s sixth defenseman during the opening round and played fewer than 11 minutes in each of the first three playoff games he appeared in. He still made an impact physically, but the deployment showed where he stood within Martin St. Louis’ defensive hierarchy.
Montreal should not trade Xhekaj simply because its blue line is crowded. Players with his size, personality and willingness to defend teammates are rarely available.
However, Kent Hughes must determine whether Xhekaj can become more than a protected third-pairing defender. If the Canadiens believe his ceiling has stabilized, moving him while demand remains strong would be defensible.
What Would an Arber Xhekaj Trade Cost?
I would not expect Montreal to accept a third-round selection as the primary return. Xhekaj’s point totals are modest, but his age, restricted free-agent status and rare physical attributes give him more market value than his offensive production suggests.
A reasonable starting point would be a second-round pick or a similarly valued young forward or prospect. Montreal would probably prefer an asset that strengthens its organizational forward depth rather than another defenseman.
Calgary should also be careful not to overpay. Xhekaj could make the Flames more difficult to play against, but he would not address their need for additional scoring or become a top-four puck mover.
That is why this rumor is more complicated than it initially appears. The player fits Calgary’s identity, but not necessarily its present depth chart.
Has the Original Calgary Flames Report Been Confirmed?
The original March report established Calgary’s interest. It did not establish active negotiations, an offer from the Flames, or an asking price from Montreal.
As of August 4, no credible public follow-up has confirmed that the two teams are currently discussing a Xhekaj trade. Calgary’s subsequent acquisition of Nemec also reduced the urgency to add another defenseman.
My expectation is that Xhekaj remains with the Montreal Canadiens unless contract negotiations stall or another team makes an aggressive offer. Calgary could re-enter the conversation if it moves an established defenseman, but the Flames are no longer the obvious landing spot they appeared to be when the interest was first reported.
Arber Xhekaj Career NHL Stats
| Type | GP | G | A | P | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Regular Season | 230 | 10 | 23 | 33 | -24 |
| Playoffs | 16 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 6 |
Find the Latest Calgary Flames News
For the latest Calgary Flames news, Montreal Canadiens rumors and updates involving Arber Xhekaj, add nhltraderumor.com to your bookmarks. While you are here, join our official NHL Hockey Pool this season to test your GM skills and compete for the ultimate bragging rights. When you are looking for how to watch the Flames game on TV today, visit our Calgary Flames TV schedule coverage and sign up for our newsletter below.
