Anthony Mantha was supposed to be a gamble. Now, he looks like one of the smartest bets the Pittsburgh Penguins have made in years. But in the cruel economy of the NHL salary cap, a player overperforming on an expiring deal doesn’t just bring goals—it brings headaches.
Here is the fast takeaway: Mantha’s resurgence has revived his value across the league. With the Penguins sitting precariously on the playoff bubble (18-12-9), GM Kyle Dubas is staring down a binary choice. If the team dips in the standings before the Olympic break, Mantha becomes a premium trade chip. If they stay afloat, he becomes an “own rental”—a risk that could see him walk for free in July, but one necessary to give Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin one last legitimate shot at glory.
The Playoff Push vs. Asset Management
The comfortable narrative suggests that if you aren’t a lock for the playoffs, you sell. But Pittsburgh is not a normal franchise. When you employ No. 87 and No. 71, “rebuilding” is a dirty word.
Mantha’s play this season has been a revelation. He has provided the secondary scoring depth that has plagued this roster for seasons. However, looking at the math, the Penguins are just one point out of a spot. The parity in the Metro Division means a bad week could bury them, while a good week could secure a seed.
If the Penguins are further down the standings by mid-February, just as the league pauses for the Olympics, the phone will ring. Contenders are starving for size and scoring touch. Mantha fits the mold of a deadline acquisition perfectly. But trading him signals a white flag to the locker room—a dangerous message to send to a core group of veterans who refuse to go gently into the night.
My Take: Why the “Own Rental” Make Sense
I’ve covered enough deadlines to know that asset management usually trumps sentimentality. However, in Pittsburgh, the context is different.
If the Penguins are anywhere near that wild card line come March, they cannot trade Anthony Mantha. You simply do not jeopardize a potential playoff run with Crosby and Malkin still producing at elite levels. The concept of the “own rental” is often criticized by fans who want draft picks, but for this specific team, in this specific year, it is the correct play.
Keeping Mantha signals to the room that management believes. Shipping him out for a 2nd or 3rd round pick might help the farm system in 2028, but it guts the soul of the 2026 team. Unless the wheels completely fall off before the Olympic break, expect Mantha to finish the season in black and gold, fighting for a postseason berth.
Get the Latest Pittsburgh Penguins News and Join the Action
Don’t miss a beat of the playoff push. For the latest breaking news, line combinations, and rumors, keep nhltraderumor.com bookmarked. Think you know who is scoring tonight? Join our Fantasy Hockey Pool for a chance to win cash prizes—it’s the best way to add stakes to every game. Also, check our “Watch” section to find out how to stream or watch the Penguins game on TV today.
To make sure you never miss a rumor, sign up for our newsletter below.
