NHL Hall of Famer Chris Pronger didn’t hold back when discussing the future of Pittsburgh Penguins captain Sidney Crosby. With Crosby having two more years on his deal, rumors are swirling about whether he will finish his career as a one-team legend or seek another Stanley Cup elsewhere.
Pronger dives deep into the dilemmas facing one of hockey’s greatest. “He’s not going to win in Pittsburgh,” Pronger states bluntly, adding, “it is going to be painful.” This stark assessment from a former rival and Stanley Cup champion himself reveals a sobering reality for Penguins fans and ignites the imagination of what could be next for Crosby.
Chris Pronger on Sidney Crosby’s Monumental Career Crossroads
“Sid’s already won three [Stanley Cups], by the way,” Pronger notes, immediately setting the stage for the high stakes involved. The central dilemma for Crosby, as articulated by Pronger, boils down to two paths: cementing his legacy as a rare one-franchise icon, akin to Mario Lemieux, Steve Yzerman, or Nicklas Lidstrom, or taking “another kick at it” to chase more championships. In an era where player movement is common, playing 20-plus years for one franchise is a remarkable feat, adding immense weight to Crosby’s decision.
Pronger suggests the biggest driver for a potential move would be the chance to win. “If he goes anywhere, it would be to a team where he thinks they can win. Otherwise, why are you gonna move?” This isn’t about personal glory alone; it’s about the competitive fire that still burns within a player of Crosby’s caliber. Pronger even playfully stirs the pot, suggesting destinations like Edmonton to play alongside McDavid and Draisaitl, or Colorado with MacKinnon, where Crosby could assume a slightly different role. “He doesn’t have to be 1A,” Pronger explains, envisioning Crosby playing a second-line center role, getting better matchups, and contributing to another contender. This strategic shift could prolong his effectiveness and increase his chances of hoisting the Cup again.
The hard truth, according to Pronger, is that “he’s not going to win in Pittsburgh.” He describes the current situation as already “painful” and foresees more struggle for the Pittsburgh Penguins. For Crosby, the prospect of “breaking his back for a team he knows is not going to win” could be psychologically draining. While it wouldn’t tarnish his existing legacy, it wouldn’t “help” him add more championships to his illustrious resume. Pronger believes Crosby has “two kicks at the can” to win more if he were to move.
Ultimately, Pronger reflects on Crosby’s mirroring of Mario Lemieux’s loyalty to the franchise and city. However, he differentiates their situations: “When you’ve won and then you start losing like that, no thank you.” The grind of losing, especially when one’s individual play is still elite, as Crosby’s undeniably is, can be taxing. Unlike Evgeni Malkin, whose play has drastically fallen off, Crosby remains near the top of his game, making the decision even more poignant. The next couple of years will be pivotal for Sidney Crosby and the Pittsburgh Penguins, as the hockey world watches to see if one of its greatest stars will prioritize loyalty or the pursuit of another Stanley Cup.
Stay Up-to-Date with the Pittsburgh Penguins
For the latest Pittsburgh Penguins news, online Hockey Pool for cash prizes, and to find out what channel the Penguins game is on TV today, make sure to add nhltraderumor.com to your bookmarks and sign up for our newsletter below.
