Is it blasphemy to vote against Connor McDavid? Usually, yes. But something is happening in San Jose that defies logic, and it might just break the NHL awards voters wide open.
Let’s be real: Connor McDavid and Nathan MacKinnon are playing a different sport than everyone else. They are posting video-game numbers, leading superteams, and doing what they always do—dominate. If you looked strictly at the stat sheet, the Hart Trophy discussion should be a two-horse race. Closed case.
But here is the twist keeping insiders up at night: Macklin Celebrini.
The 19-year-old phenom isn’t just scoring; he is single-handedly dragging a franchise from the abyss back into relevance. And according to the latest buzz from the TSN OverDrive panel, if the San Jose Sharks sneak into the playoffs, the MVP narrative might shift violently in his favor. Are we witnessing legitimate greatness, or just a severe case of “Voter Fatigue”?
The “Voter Fatigue” Factor
There is a dirty little secret in NHL awards voting: people get bored of greatness. We saw it with John Cooper never winning the Jack Adams despite historic seasons. We see it now with the McDavid vs. MacKinnon debate.
As the panel noted, voters are human. They love a story. When McDavid puts up 150 points, we yawn and say, “That’s just Connor being Connor.” It’s the baseline. But when a sophomore like Celebrini is putting up 125+ points on a team that was essentially a lottery lock for half a decade? That is a narrative that catches fire.
One panelist put it bluntly: “If the San Jose Sharks get into the playoffs, Macklin Celebrini gets your vote. Absolutely. Blindly.”
Is it fair? Maybe not. Is it reality? 100%.
The “Narrative” MVP vs. The Statistical MVP
Let’s look at the supporting cast. This is the strongest argument in Celebrini’s favor.
Nathan MacKinnon passes the puck to Cale Makar, the undisputed best defenseman in the world. Connor McDavid has Leon Draisaitl, a perennial 100-point monster.
Macklin Celebrini? He’s making magic with a much younger, rawer core. He’s dishing to Will Smith and relying on a defensive group that, while improved with veterans like John Klingberg and Timothy Liljegren, isn’t exactly the ’76 Canadiens. He doesn’t have the luxury of a safety net. If Celebrini takes a night off, the Sharks lose. If McDavid takes a night off, the Oilers might still put up five goals.
That is the definition of value.
The Eye Test: That “Lemieux-Gretzky” Fake
Stats are great, but the Hart Trophy is often won in moments. And Celebrini is delivering moments.
The panel highlighted a recent goal that sealed a massive divisional win—a fake so convincing it looked like something out of a Mario Lemieux highlight reel. It wasn’t just a goal; it was a statement. It showed a 19-year-old who isn’t just surviving in the NHL; he’s toying with it.
When you see a kid doing that in crunch time—fighting for a Wild Card spot in a brutal Pacific Division against Vegas and Edmonton—it resonates. It proves the moment isn’t too big for him.
A Legit Chance?
Here is the verdict: Yes, he has a legit chance. But it comes with a massive asterisk.
The Sharks must make the playoffs.
If San Jose finishes 9th, Celebrini is an incredible story, but the Hart goes to the heavy hitters in Edmonton or Colorado. But if they cross that line? If they secure a playoff berth led by a teenager?
That is “Voter Fraud” territory according to the purists, but it’s “MVP” territory for everyone else. McDavid might be the best player in the world, but this season, Celebrini might be the most valuable.
Stay Updated with NHL Trade Rumors
Want to keep a pulse on the Sharks’ playoff push? We are tracking every shift. Whether you are looking for finding the latest San Jose Sharks news, want to join our Fantasy Hockey Pool for cash prizes, or need to check the NHL point leaders 2025-26, we have you covered on our website.
Make sure to add nhltraderumor.com to your bookmarks today and sign up for our newsletter below to never miss a beat.
